This review was first published in The Student Pocket Guide
Grab your boots! We’re off on the walking trip of a lifetime! A Walk In The Woods is
an adaptation of Bill Bryson’s travel memoir of the same name, which
recounted his attempt to walk the 2,200 mile Appalachian Trail with his
long-lost friend Stephen Katz. Miles of breathtaking scenery, top banter
and new experiences galore makes for a great book but, unfortunately,
the same can’t be said for the film.
Flying in the face of warnings that such a long hiking trip is
madness (not least from his wife, played by the ever-wonderful Emma
Thompson), Bill Bryson (Robert Redford) sets out on one last big
adventure to find peace and tranquility. The only trouble is, his
walking partner Katz (a ruddy-faced Nick Nolte) has a rather different
idea of what the hike will offer, namely an escape from unpaid debts and
potential prison time.
The genesis of a screen adaptation of A Walk In The Woods has
been a long one, and one which has been overseen by Redford for some
ten years. Redford hoped to bring Paul Newman on board but Newman’s
death in 2008 stalled the project. When Nick Nolte took on the role of
Stephen Katz, who is as cantankerous as any walking partner could be,
the book’s long hike into cinemas was nearly complete.
Opening with Bill Bryson giving a TV interview in which he can’t seem
to get a word in edgeways, the film paints Bryson as a restless and
discontented writer whose literary success and countless awards count
for little. In order for him to be happy in retirement, a new adventure
of self-reflection is needed. In reality, Bryson was in his 40s when he
walked the trail, slightly different from Redford who will be
celebrating his 80th birthday next year. This fact defines
the film, which is stuffed full with geriatric jokes and laughs which
revolve around Nolte and Redford’s longing for the good old days.
Anyone who has read Bill Bryson’s humorous and effortless prose will
be ultimately disappointed with Ken Kwapis’ film. Glimpses of Bryson’s
writing struggle through the screenplay which, unfortunately, is riddled
with clichés and pedestrian dialogue. This is not to say that
proceedings are devoid of any laughs, and occasional one-liners elicit a
few chuckles. Nolte’s performance as Bryson’s washed-up companion also
raises a few smiles but his gruff tones and bickering with Redford all
seem a bit uninspired and unremarkable.
As the pair trudge through beautiful scenery (shot with a
quasi-travel documentary edge), encounter bears and constantly bemoan
their advanced age, their journey of self-reflection and redemption is
pleasant enough to watch but one can’t help feeling that the whole thing
is rather inconsequential. A thread of sentimentality runs throughout
the film but, at times, borders on the ridiculous, especially when we
see our protagonists in their sleeping bags staring up at the stars and
pondering on opportunities missed and the futility of their lives.
On an overall level, A Walk In The Woods feels as if a tired
and weary Kwapis made it the day after finishing the Appalachian Trail
himself: the energy of Bryson’s writing is lost and the film’s lethargic
pace threatens to smother the rather enjoyable comedic tone of the
film. In essence, it’s less of a walk, and more of a slog through the
woods.
Clapperboard Rating: * *
No comments:
Post a Comment