The cynic in me would
say that studio bosses would have received the news of Nelson
Mandela's death with mixed feelings. Sadness and respect, of course,
but I can't help wondering that the timing of his death could be seen
as something of a positive for those with a financial and a creative
interest in Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom.
People will go and see the film for many reasons: to reflect on
Mandela's life and legacy, to see Idris Elba's performance or, like
me, to simply learn more about the man and his achievements. From
this point of view, Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom is
an informative biopic and will give the audience a run-down of the
major milestones and events in Mandela's life. This, however, does
not necessarily make for a great cinematic experience.
Mandela: Long Walk
to Freedom can't be knocked for
its ambitious scope: it attempts to tell Mandela's story from his
coming-of-age ceremony in the South African savannah, to his election
as President in 1994. Idris Elba takes on the role and, for the most
part, gives a nuanced and accomplished performance which captivates
the audience from the very beginning. He is a commanding screen presence and, placed alongside Naomie Harris as his headstrong wife
Winnie, is certainly one of the film's strengths. Harris' portrayal
of Winnie's transformation is also very interesting to watch: from
doting and vulnerable new wife and mother, to militant campaigner,
Winnie's story is just as engaging as that of Mandela.
Elba
is particularly assured when playing Mandela as a young man, charting
his involvement with the ANC and exploring his attitudes towards
violence and his experiences in prison. The problem here, however, is
that the film feels a little too referential and merely skims the
surface of Mandela's personal conflicts. Of course, a film charting
the monumental events of Mandela's life was never going to have
enough time but it often felt that the film was going through the
motions, ticking off the milestones: a whistle-stop Mandela Tour.
The
film is shot beautifully by Lol Crawley and the images of rural South
Africa are particularly striking. Some have criticised the film's
score as being too emotionally manipulative but I feel that it fits
with the film's tone: this is not an exposé of some aspects of
Mandela's life or a revelatory film: it is a dramatic summary, if you
will, of Mandela. Its primary function is to be an emotive drama and
its score reflects this. During scenes of prison visits by Mandela's
family, the prison guard demands that the visits are conducted with the
proviso that the conversations will include “no politics”. Some
will disagree, but I think that, similarly, the film's own politics
are less evident than they could be. This is not necessarily,
however, a weakness.
Perhaps
the central issue is this: does the film's subject-matter – based
on the life and achievements of one of the most influential figures
of modern times – automatically create a film of value and
importance? The answer is no, it doesn't. Many will, perhaps, be
disappointed with Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom because
it fails to offer any more information than Mandela's Wikipedia
entry. South Africa may look stunning, the cast may be captivating
and the events portrayed may be exciting and affecting. But it's all
too neat. At the beginning of this review, I asked whether or not
biopics can make great cinematic experiences. Mandela: Long
Walk to Freedom is not a triumph
of cinema because, paradoxically, it is too cinematic, too polished
and too referential.
Clapperboard Rating: * * *
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom is released nationwide on 3rd January 2014